Christians, We Need to Talk About This Knee-Jerk Reaction to God’s Love

There’s a strange reaction I’ve noticed in some Christian circles.

Say, “God is loving and kind,” and almost immediately someone feels the need to counter:

“Yes, but He’s also just and righteous!”

It’s not that the statement is wrong—God is just and righteous, and His love is not at odds with His holiness.

But the reflex says something.

It reveals that for many, God’s love and God’s justice are still at war in their minds.

As if His kindness needs to be balanced by severity. As if His mercy needs to be held in check by judgment. As if Jesus has to be softened by Moses.

But that’s not the Gospel.

That’s not the heart of the Father.

And that’s not the God Jesus revealed.

Where Does This Reaction Come From?

Some of it comes from fear-based theology, shaped by a lens that sees God as mostly disappointed or angry, always needing to be appeased.

That creates a low view of love and a high view of wrath—and when someone emphasizes love, it feels threatening, almost like letting God’s “seriousness” slip.

But there’s another reason this reaction shows up:

Many Christians have seen a distorted, shallow version of love. One that excuses sin, avoids truth, and becomes a spiritual “get out of jail free card.”

They’ve witnessed “love” used to justify compromise, perversion, or spiritual laziness.

So now, when someone says “God is loving,” their gut response is, "But He’s also holy. Let’s not forget He has standards."

The concern is valid—but the correction is misplaced.

Because the answer to counterfeit love is not less love.

It’s a return to true agape love—the kind that’s fierce, pure, and transformative.

“The holiness of God and the love of God are not at odds. One does not cancel out the other. In Christ, they are perfectly one.” — A.W. Tozer

The love of God is not weak, mushy, or passive.

It’s strong. It convicts. It restores.

It doesn’t excuse sin—it overcomes it.

Jesus Is What God Looks Like

"The Son is the radiance of God’s glory and the exact representation of His being..." (Hebrews 1:3)

Jesus is not the softer side of God.

He’s the full picture of God.

And when Jesus steps into the world, we see what true justice looks like:

  • He restores the woman caught in adultery (John 8), rather than stone her.

  • He welcomes the sinner, but never leaves them the same.

  • He rebukes the religious who wielded justice as a weapon.

  • He touches the leper, weeps over death, confronts corruption, and lays down His life for enemies.

In Jesus, we see that justice is not retribution—it’s restoration.

Love doesn’t weaken holiness—it reveals it.

Righteousness That Heals, Not Harms

"But let justice roll down like waters, and righteousness like an ever-flowing stream." (Amos 5:24)

Righteousness in Scripture isn’t just about behavior—it’s about relationship.

Being aligned with God.

Living in right relationship with others.

Healing what’s been broken.

God’s justice doesn’t destroy—it delivers.

C.S. Lewis put it like this:

“We are not told that God is justice, or God is power, or God is wrath. We are told that God is love.”

And that love is not a soft cushion for sin.

It is a holy fire that transforms from the inside out.

Analogy: The Broken Vase

Picture a child knocking over a valuable vase. Two parents react:

  • One says, “They broke it. They need to be punished.”

  • The other says, “They’re hurt. The vase is broken. Let’s clean it up, talk through what happened, and reassure them they’re still loved.”

The second isn’t soft—it’s wise. It corrects with care. It restores with love.

That’s what justice looks like in the Kingdom.

So Why the Reflex?

Because people have seen the word “love” misused.

They’ve watched grace get reduced to passivity.

They’ve seen truth abandoned in the name of tolerance.

And they’ve been burned by a gospel that felt empty.

But instead of reacting by retreating into law, we need to rediscover love as it truly is: holy, healing, and whole.

Let’s Stop Dividing What God Has United

We don’t need to “balance” God’s love with His justice.

We need to redefine justice through His love.

Jesus never said, “Go and sin no more—but remember, I’m also just.” His mercy was justice.

His kindness was righteousness.

His embrace was holiness in action.

  • The problem isn’t too much love. It’s too little of the real kind.

  • God’s justice doesn’t oppose His love—it expresses it.

  • Mercy isn’t the exception to justice; it’s the deepest form of it.

  • If your view of justice leads you away from love, you’re not seeing it through Jesus.

  • Kindness isn’t soft—it’s kingdom strength.

Let’s stop flinching when someone says “God is kind.”

Let’s stop slapping disclaimers onto the Good News.

Let’s stop acting like love needs a warning label.

Because in Jesus, the love of God and the justice of God are not in tension—they are in harmony.

Not two sides. One face. One heart. One perfect King.

Let that be the justice we proclaim.

Questions for reflection

1. Have I unknowingly viewed God’s justice as something separate from—or even opposed to—His love?

2. When I hear that God is kind and loving, do I instinctively feel the need to “balance” that with warnings or conditions? Why?

3. Am I letting the fullness of Jesus reshape my view of God, or am I still holding onto old frameworks rooted in fear or distortion?

Bless you,

Lee


Here are 3 simple ways to step out of striving and into a steady, peaceful life of God:

1. Coaching: Break free from striving and learn how to actually live from God's goodness—with clarity, peace, and real intimacy. Learn more here.

2. One-off Call: If you feel stuck or overwhelmed, this is a focused space to bring clarity and settle what's been weighing on you. Learn more here.

3. Snuggle Strategy mini-course: If your faith feels heavy, this will help you rediscover the restful way of Jesus. Learn more here.

🙋‍♂️

I keep my emails simple and easy. If you find value in what I share, come join me.

PS: check your spam/junk folder just incase, and mark my auto-reply email as safe.